--> -->

GameFly vs Blockbuster - Who Do I Give My Money To?

by PacoDG

toasteeeeee

Video game rentals, we all have to do it. With titles that come out like Shadowrun, that may seem “kinda cool” in some ways, but you know in your heart you can’t justify plunking down $60 for a game you just aren’t sure about, we as gamers have to rely on game rental services. I started writing this a little over a month ago, noticing that Blockbuster had 6 copies of Transformers (all on the shelf), while their one copy of Overlord they ordered for the store had not even arrived yet. Quickly, I went home with a copy of F.E.A.R. and the desire to find something better. Let it be known, I have been using the Blockbuster GamePass service through my little brother for well over a year now, the most obvious problem with them however, is they are Blockbuster, or as I know them, ‘the devil.’ I have been using Netflix for many many moons now and with that I have a certain bitterness with Blockbuster as far as late fees plus crappy selection of movies, but hey, this is about the games.

Off to the Internets, I knew that Gamefly was the big contender here, but I wanted to find something else, I had already heard the stories of Gamefly discs being stolen by mailmen as well as their horrid turnaround shipping times. I remember the company Gameznflix.com, they have to be good, they were smart enough to jump into the extremely small market of online video game rentals early on, and at the same time compete with Netflix to be the Blockbuster of online (I am ignoring that ‘the devil’ has an online service of their own, damn my bias). So off to check online reviews of GameznFlix… oh man, not good. Coming from the CAG forums, in a sea of many quotes I could pull from, here is my favorite, “I’m done with Gameznflix. I had 20 games in my queue, half new, half old, and they failed to ship me a single game after 14 days.” Even the guys at XBL Radio have dropped support of the company. Want more current GameznFlix issues, look no further than NeoGAF.

Off to the Internets again. Gottaplay.com, seems to be right under GameznFlix in terms of exposure, however I could not find many reviews, just their name. So in the interest of good journalism (not my desire to get Overlord of course), I went ahead and signed up to at the least, check out their availability.

July 2nd, 11:56pm, signed up, put in “The Darkness” and “Overlord” .. both came up with GameStatus not available. Account Canceled right away, damn I am impatient.

July 2nd (technically the 3rd) 12:08am, signed up on Gamefly. What is this, a deal, only $15.65 a month for the first 3 months and a free subscription to “Official Xbox Magazine,” im sold, thoughts of evil mailmen and bad shipping times are tossed aside. I throw in my queue The Darkness and Overlord.

July 5th hits, Overlord is still in “Low Availability” and The Darkness has now moved into “Very Low” status. Out of the other games in my queue, Condemned for whatever reason has moved down to “Medium.” Later in the night when adding more games to my queue, I note Overlord is now “Very Low” … but.. The Darkness has been shipped!

July 8th, I receive two games. I want to make note I am enjoying the Spider-Man 3 game waaaay more than I though I would, still, I decided to send it back as a test to see how long it takes before I get another game (c’mon, I wasn’t going to give up The Darkness, which I still currently have).

July 12th, though Spider-Man 3 is listed as a game I still have out, my next game in queue (well not truly next game… but one that was available on the list) is now being sent, thanks to that “Fast Return” service which I was kind of questionable on. I have to note something about GameFly that I do find nice, is a feature in the Xbox 360 section, a list of original Xbox games that are playable on the 360, already all separated for you. Its a simple thing, but nice for those non-internet geeks that may not know the full list of games off hand (nor want to know that).

July 16th, they finally received the Spider-Man 3 game I turned in last week. So a full week turn around time, not that great, I want to give GameFly the benefit of the doubt and say that this isn’t like a movie off Netflix, where you watch it once, maybe twice, and then return. Where as you tend to have a game title for at least a week, so while playing one, you maybe don’t worry about that week turn around time. However, not giving them the benefit of the doubt, a week is a long ass time, thank Jeebus for this “Fast Return” service, the east coast shipping facility seems to be broken, as I haven’t received any games from them yet (August 13th), so far all from the California shipping facility.

(Skip ahead a few weeks, as I have been playing The Darkness and a copy of Overlord that my brother was able to nab eventually from Blockbuster)

August 3rd, mailed out Big Brain Academy Wii. I didn’t even play it, I realized if it has been sitting on my desk for that long, maybe it was time to just go ahead and forget about it so I can already get the next game in my queue.

August 9th, they FINALLY received it. No “Fast Return” service was used on this title, I wonder what why. Next game shipped out, but it was one way down on my queue, bah, I really want to play Condemned. That’s it, this comparison is over!

Blockbuster has owned GameFly in my quest for Overlord, but overall it is still kind of hard to say either service has truly outdone the other. I am not canceling my GameFly account yet, but this is only because I am up odd hours where I am basically either working or sleeping during most of Blockbuster’s open hours (I am nearly graveyard shift), however, I definitely know this is not the case of John Q Public. Blockbuster ties you down to one store if you use GamePass, that sucks as you are limited to that store’s selection, on top of, if you just want to rent games with them, enjoy spending almost ten bucks plus whatever late fees occur after the week you get to have with your rental. GameFly, I am trying to have faith in them, I will be sticking with them for a little while more, I remember reading an article that had found through some Internet Matlockery, they are going to open up a facility in Texas (link). I pray that this will help not only with their turnaround time, but their availability as well.

So it comes down to, if you want speed and don’t mind paying more for it, Blockbuster, if you want selection at a cheaper cost, give GameFly a try (and do it through this link, referral credit ftw). I really believe the service only has one way to go, up, unless Netflix smartens up and starts a video game division, then it’s all over for these other online rental services.

Did You Enjoy this Post? Subscribe to XBox 360 Rally. It's Free!

7 Responses to “GameFly vs Blockbuster - Who Do I Give My Money To?”

  1. Jdtosh Says:

    Well, well, blockbuster scrapes by with 1 game. Fact is, Gamefly’s library is at about 5,000+ games, the largest. Blockbuster library (more like a shelf) is crap.
    Fast return is a service of the post office, some don’t have scanners, check with you local post offices.
    I think u made the right move sticking with gamefly, if you want every game available to you. I’ve really been stoked on the service recently.

  2. Hoodoo Says:

    Gamefly has been great for me. I dropped them after a year because of cheap cost ($12.75 a month for 3 games) posts on CAG for Gameznflix.com. You get what you pay for… the service reeked. I wanted TMNT for 360 and Ratchet and Clank for PSP, and even a month after they have been released, Gameznflix.com showed them “On Order”, which means they never had the game to begin with.

    So, I went back to Gamefly, where BioShock was shipped the day before release and arrived the day after release. The thing to remember is if you want a new release game, put it at the top of your queue and make sure nothing else can ship… works everytime. Now… I am off to the murky waters of Rapture.

  3. Tom Says:

    Bioshock shipped for me to. so awesome. i agree. gamefly is best on selection definately and turnaround and games has been reaching me in record time. best service around for gettin the games i want for cheaps.

    blockbuster might be good for movies but for games…NOT.

  4. 1P Start » Blog Archive » GameFly Just Got Better - East Coast Distribution Says:

    [...] Distribution by PacoDG In the past I have tried many different rental services for games. When I last wrote up a bout between Blockbuster and GameFly, I still had enjoyed Blockbusters service, but a lazy part of me enjoyed [...]

  5. 1P Start » Blog Archive » GameFly Third Distribution Center Opens (Again?) Says:

    [...] plus who doesn’t like to get mail (and honestly, there is a part of me that has a lot of faith in GameFly to get up to par with [...]

  6. 1P Start » Blog Archive » “We will never go back to Vegas” - Rainbow Six Says:

    [...] thin, I think Xbox Live activity numbers can attest to that, Rainbow Six Vegas ended up being a rental rather than a buy for a lot (or at least CoD4 and Halo 3 has stopped everyone on my friends list [...]

  7. 1P Start » Blog Archive » New Releases: Week of February 17th, 2008 Says:

    [...] DS? check out the Flash Demo of the game here, very cool). Check out the full list below, lots of GameFly queue material [...]

Leave a Reply


About XBox 360 Rally

Welcome to Xbox 360 Rally, the only home for all the Xbox 360 news that matters, with a touch of “home flavor” not associated with most major gaming sites. Xbox 360 Rally brings you all the Xbox 360 News, Reviews and Previews you could ever ask for, with a healthy dose of sarcasm, and a dash of cynicism to get you through your day.

XBox 360 Rally Author(s)
    » Lulu-Mcgrew

Blogging Flair

--> -->

Gaming Channel Posts

  • BioShock: More Like Ayn Rand Than Initially Thought
    [caption id="attachment_1934" align="alignleft" width="300" caption="A new splicer for BioShock 2...The Old-timey Football Splicer!"][/caption] A little while ago, I finally started playing [...]
  • Sam and Max Hit the 360
    One my favorite PC adventure games of all times was Sam and Max Hit the Road. Not only did it fit right into the perfect definition of an amazing adventure game, but the adventures of the [...]
  • Where's My EGM?
    The question that I'm asking today is just where the heck is my EGM? Okay, I know the magazine Electronic Gaming Monthly or commonly referred to as EGM went under when they were sold by their [...]
  • My Quest for RTS on the Xbox 360: Halo Wars and Stormrise
    When I was 17, I started playing a game called Civilization. The first time I saw the sun rise after an all-nighter, I knew I was hooked. I have met others afflicted with this addiction to strategy [...]
  • Rock Band 2 Singer
    We have been playing a lot of Rock Band 2 for the Wii. One song that I absolutely adore is Duran Duran's 'Hungry like the wolf.' It has always been one of my favorite. I remember having the album [...]
  • Live Wii Fit
    I just saw a commercial for Wii Fit that was unlike any video game commercial I have ever seen. It advertised LiveWiiFit.com. The commercial was almost like a short infomercial. Of course with the [...]
  • What are Your Favorite Types of Games and Why?
    I recently had a job interview for a temp job. The agency asked me a lot of video game related questions including, "What are you favorite types of games and why?" It put my off a little, because [...]
  • X-Blades is X-Awesome
    So I know nothing about X-Blades, except my roommate got it free at his work. Oh yeah, and there was something about censoring the cover art. Other than that, I got nothing. It's strange though, [...]
  • Warning: You Can Lose Achievements if Your Email Dies
    Talk about a bad bug. According to Gameindustry.biz, there's a flaw in Xbox Live where if your Windows Live ID email address is deactivated due to things like it being an old email address that [...]
  • Onechanbara: Bikini Samurai Squad Nudity
    I know nothing about Onechanbara: Bikini Samurai Squad, except there's girls in bikinis and there's some sort of fighting supernatural monsters. I don't know why this isn't a rated R movie yet. [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Gagne Story..Full Details, Dibiase "One More Match", More Wishes Granted
    -Mike Mooneyham has got a great cover story of the Venre Gagne incident. {Wrestling legend linked to tragic nursing home death} -Sun's UK has got an story of Ted Dibiase "The Million Dollar Man" [...]
  • Samsung to produce 12.1-inch “Mini-notebook” with Via Nano
    Curtesy of JK on the Run: The official word comes today that Samsung is going to produce a 12.1-inch notebook, the NC20. The NC20 is a larger cousin to the NC10 netbook from Samsung and this larger [...]
  • Bobby Lashley Movie Role, WWE and Kmart, Legends of WrestleMania Screenshots
    -Bobby Lashley has landed a part in an upcoming movie The Way of Way, starring Cuba Gooding, Jr. Lashley will fight Omar Gooding's brother in an underground fight scene. The movie will also feature [...]
  • Beckford wins SEC long jump
    The Razorbacks sit in first place with 45 points in the team race after two days of events. [...]
  • Ochoa Wins in Thailand; Ogilvy Fails to Break A Sweat to Win Match Play
    [caption id="attachment_745" align="alignleft" width="248" caption="AP Photo/Matt York"][/caption] In what was, I dare say, a very boring final in the World Golf Championships - Accenture Match [...]
  • Is the National Disaster Over?
    It looks like the Washington Nationals are finally moving on and trying to get back to the business of baseball on the field; not off of it. According to the AP, Jim Bowden resigned Sunday after four [...]
  • Blood Pressure Control Key For Black Diabetics
    [caption id="attachment_826" align="alignnone" width="128" caption="Pills"][/caption]Keeping blood pressure down is critical for African Americans with type 2 diabetes as high pressures increase the [...]
  • Free Physical Activities Workbook from AARP
    How do you get your clients to increase their physical activity? They can start by lifting one of these. Motivating your clients to increase their physical activity isn't easy. AARP's Physical [...]
  • Video of Brad Leaving JFK
    I stumbled onto this video this morning of Brad heading out of JFK. It really shows you (once again) what it must be like to try to do something as simple as walking through an airport when you're [...]
  • Heyman's Mom Passes Away, Shelly Martinez Update, Rare Mysterio Footage - Video
    -The Wrestling Observer reports: Paul Heyman's mom, 81 year old Sulamita passed away yesterday morning as she had recently been in poor health. Sulamita was a survivor of the Nazi Holocaust. [...]